Untitled design-3.png

Bagel Pantry

Hand-rolled bagels. Boiled fresh daily.



134 South Plainfield Ave

South Plainfield, NJ 07080

Mon - Fri , 5am - 4pm

Sat & Sun , 5am - 3pm

545 Middlesex Ave

Metuchen, NJ 08840

Mon - Fri , 5am - 6pm

Sat , 5am - 5pm

Sun , 5am - 3pm

Find us!

Call us!

Find us!

Call us!

518 Millburn Ave

Millburn/Short Hills, NJ 07078

Mon - Sat , 5am - 4pm

Sun , 5am - 3pm

Find us!

Call us!

Screen Shot 2018-12-09 at 11.14.09 AM.jp

In 1983, one out of the three founders of Bagel Pantry immigrated from Palestine to The United States and ended up right here in New Jersey. He worked in several Bagel Shops around the state and when two of his other brothers also immigrated from Palestine, they decided to open up a shop of their own.


On February 17, 1997 Bagel Pantry opened for business. At the time, there was only one location, on Plainfield Avenue in South Plainfield. However, as business grew, the brothers expanded and opened up another shop in Metuchen, New Jersey. Over the years, the store grew into the hearts of locals and became a tradition in South Plainfield & Metuchen.



Interested in Our Special Catering Services? 

Please fill out this form so we can personalize a catering package for your upcoming event.

Thanks for submitting!